7 years, 9 months ago
Philip Smucker in the Asia Times:
Although the US is not technically losing, it would be extremely hard to argue that Afghanistan’s safety has not been sacrificed due to the policies of a risk-averse American government. A basic premise of the US military’s own strategy is that ultimate success is gained “by protecting the populace, not the counter-insurgency force”. This principle is violated daily.
The Pentagon’s high-tech-centric approach to the fight in Afghanistan has produced – since 9/11 – a half-dozen gargantuan bases – with more on the way. These are little more than anachronistic monuments to the US military’s superior firepower. At Bagram and Jalalabad air bases, aerial drones, commanded by joystick pilots in the deserts of Nevada, circle and land. Invisible F-16s and F-15s lay figure-eight smoke trails in the blue skies above Tora Bora. At dusk, the snow line of the Hindu Kush is flush with Apache attack helicopters and larger Chinooks. None of them are the key to victory.
In the last several months of living and talking to American soldiers and officers in the field, particularly along the eastern front, I have been impressed with their understanding of what it will take to win in Afghanistan. One enthusiastic young Southerner, Major Tommy Cardone, boiled it down to a useful campaign slogan, “It’s the people, stupid!” Indeed, I was left with the impression that the US military does have a strategy; if only the cautious generals and politicians in Washington will allow it to be implemented.
To win in Afghanistan, the US military – and its Afghan partners – must follow best-practices counter-insurgency down to the last of Afghanistan’s 40,000 villages. Only by taking the fight – along with Afghan soldiers and policemen – to the countryside will the Taliban be isolated and excluded from what Chairman Mao Zedong once referred to as the sea of the people.
Regular readers know that we have always held a nuanced view of counterinsurgency. There is no reason for FM 3-24 to place protection of the population in juxtaposition over against killing insurgents. It isn’t an EITHER-OR choice. It is BOTH-AND. They are corollary and coupled propositions, not a dilemma. See for instance the Marine operations in Helmand in 2008 in which the Marines killed some 400 Taliban fighters, but also in which the population made it clear that they wanted the Marines to stay. From our Following the Marines Through Helmand III:
Take particular note of the words of town elder Abdul Nabi: “We are grateful for the security. We don’t need your help, just security.” Similar words were spoken at a meeting in Ghazni with the U.S. Ambassador to Afghanistan: ““We don’t want food, we don’t want schools, we want security!” said one woman council member.”
Again, similar words were spoken upon the initial liberation of Garmser by the U.S. Marines: “The next day, at a meeting of Marines and Afghan elders, the bearded, turban-wearing men told Marine Capt. Charles O’Neill that the two sides could “join together” to fight the Taliban. “When you protect us, we will be able to protect you,” the leader of the elders said.”
The narrative emerging is not one of largesse, roads, education, crop rotation, irrigation and all of the other elements of the soft side of counterinsurgency. To be sure, these elements are necessary and good, but sequentially they come after security.
While it isn’t necessarily true – this narrative of the Army on large FOBs in Iraq until Petraeus arrrived (some Army units were conducting dismounted patrols and living amongst the people) – this problem of gargantuan bases in Afghanistan seems to be recurring. Andrew Lubin, who has also been to Afghanistan and comments wisely on his experiences, says:
Get the Army off their huge stupid bases where bureaucracy flourishes. Put them in the field where they belong. Their “creature comforts” have gotten out of control…Burger Kings, Orange Julius, jewelry stores, -do you know they now offer massage services at Bagram? In a war zone?
Even many of the Army SOF are base-bound except for their forays into the wild via helicopter rides to the next raid. Some Army are doing it right (e.g., the Korangal Valley), as are the Marines in Helmand. But the gargantuan bases are an obstacle to success in Afghanistan. Empty them. Send the Army on dismounted patrols, open vehicle patrol bases, smaller FOBs, and combat outposts. Get amongst the people. Only then will they sense that you are committed and give you intelligence – leading ultimately to killing Taliban, which will then further contribute to their security, and so on the process goes.
cheap ativan buy pharmacy online now Buy Xanax Mastercard Ups “cheapest alprazolam”
buy valium phillipines; Buy Brand Name Xanax buy alprazolam
buy valium us pharmacy Buy Xanax Online Us Pharmacy buy non genaric ambien online?
xanax order online no prescription Xanax Order Online No Prescription xanax cheap no prescription,
xanax sales online, Buy Generic Ambien At Medstore what color is generic xanax
buy xanax without perscription Buy Xanax By Check cheap alprazolam order now no prescription;
ambien fedex Cheapest Ambien Lr Online discount generic xanax?
buy brand name xanax Cheap Diazepam Index cheapest xanax pills
ativan lorazepam buy cheap ativan online Zolpidem Cheap lorazepam on line fedex
ambien cr buy fed ex delivery Buy 2mg Xanax Without Prescription buy alprazolam from mexico
cheap generic overseas ativan Valium To Order cheap ambien without prescription
buy diazepam saturday delivery; Buying Xanax While In China buy valium madre natura
ativan for sale; Xanax For Sale No Prescription cheap diazepam?
xanax generic price Buy Alprazolam Next Day Delivery order ambien from canada
cheapest xanax no prescription Panic Disorder Xanax xanax peach pill
valium cheap Order Valium 32 all about buy xanax?
buying xanax without presciption Apotex Generic Ambien ambien blue pill
xanax compare prices Cheap Ativan Buy Pharmacy Online Now prices for sleep aid ambien
valium online order Xanax Online Fedex No Prior Prescription buy xanax from india no rx
buy cheap ambien; Buy Generic Ambien On Sale pharmacies that send xanax by fedex
“order xanax online” Order Alprazolam Lorazepam depresses hiccups diazepam ups shipping 95.
buy ativan from discount store! Buy Prescription Drugs Xanax cheap ativan online discount pharmacy