Smith & Wesson M&P 5.7 Review
BY Herschel SmithMike does a very good job of the review in this video.
I was hoping that it was a hammer fired gun. It is. I wouldn’t have been even a little bit interested if it was a striker fired gun.
I also very much like the operating system, and the narrowness of the frame. It’s narrowness means that it would be easy and comfortable to conceal for IWB carry at the 3:00 position (my preferred position). I don’t appendix carry.
Finally, I like the price point. So this gun meets all of my criteria. But I will have to say that that gap he’s talking about between the slide and frame is similar to the M&P design. I’ve never picked up an M&P that didn’t have that same gap. Apparently, the S&W engineers prefer that design for some reason. Maybe someone who knows about this will weigh in.
I may have to look into this model.
My only real issue with the 5.7 is ammo availability. The cartridge has been around for more than 20 years and you still don’t see it on the shelf in a lot of stores. It’s also expensive for what it is especially compared to 9mm.
I know. Guns shows are a source of ammo, as well as online.
“Ammoseek 5.7.”
Herschel will you repost if you previously written about or newly post an article articulating your concerns with striker fired pistols?
To second Travis’ question on striker vs hammer, I’d be interested as well
At over 60 cents a round no thanks. I don’t need another safe queen.
I’ve never written extensively on the topic.
In general, striker fired guns have a striker, of course, that is half-cocked, with the pull of the trigger cocking it all the way. They don’t have a tactile feel (there are exceptions with really good trigger designs), and to me feel grinding and gritty.
Hammer fired guns have the following things mostly in common: frame-mounted safety, the ability to leave the gun cocked with the safety engaged, the ability to decock it with a round in the chamber (where cocking it is by choice), and the tactile feel of a hammer dropping off of the sear to discharge a round.
Of course, this isn’t always the case. Some hammer fired pistols are SA/DA, some hammer fired pistols don’t have good trigger designs and the sear isn’t polished enough, etc.
But in general, I don’t enjoy the feel of striker fired guns and don’t do as well with them regardless of the amount of practice (there are exceptions, the Springfield Armory XDMs, etc.). I shoot Glocks okay, not great.
But there are always exceptions to everything.
Re: “I’ve never picked up an M&P that didn’t have that same gap. Apparently, the S&W engineers prefer that design for some reason.”
With the caveat that this is speculation on my part and nothing more, maybe that gap was left in place on that M&P due to the known propensity of some designs with very close tolerances to mal’f or jam when hot, dirty or fouled. I am not a materials scientist, but could it also have something to do with the slide and frame being made of different substances with different coefficients of expansion? You’re the engineer; you tell me….
Ghetto music? Really? WTF