When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
9 Comments
Oldest
NewestMost Voted
Bad_Brad
6 years ago
Leave it off. The only round I’d recommend a forward assist on an AR for would be 7.62 by 39. Very dirty blamo. Slick side are the way to go.
Houston
6 years ago
I have a BRN-605 upper on a build. Very nice piece of kit. Fast becoming my favorite configuration. KISS.
John
6 years ago
There was a time when the Army had big problems with the powder that was being
loaded into the 5.56×45. The fouling caused jams and gave the rifle a bad reputation
that it earned because of the Army powder screwup. That is the main reason the assist
was added. I understand the new stuff is supposed to work fine but I remember in
the first Iraq invasion that a truck outfit became lost, got into a firefight and was
rolled over and they captured the woman US soldier who was later rescued.
One of the top sergeants involved in the fiasco stated that their weapons malfunctuned
because the truckers “failed to properly lubricate their rifles”.
I used the M16 A1 rifle through the early and mid 70’s and having been bitten by jams,
I will never own one.
Author
Herschel Smith
6 years ago
@John,
It’s odd how first impressions cause views for life.
I’ve never even once, in tens of thousands of rounds, had a FTF or FTE in any AR pattern rifle, and I’ve worked them pretty hard.
John
6 years ago
@ Herschel
It seems I’m like lhe guy who bought a lemon car from a particular company and avoided
their products for the rest of his life. I guess it’s old fashioned to be that way but since I’m
old myself I suppose I’m stuck with it. I do dearly love the M 14 and its clones.
Silence DoGood
6 years ago
All BCGs have a dished area that is accessible throught the ejection port that will give purchase to your thumb or a couple of fingers so you can apply a moderate amount of forward pressure to it. Applying any more force than that is the mechanical equivalent of bashing the end of the bolt on a bolt-action with a rubber mallet to force it into battery. Correcting a failure to feed or other OOB stoppage in this fashion is highly likely to further result in a failure to extract. In no case is a percussion adjustment likely to fix the root problem so instead of beating on the forward assist, better you should fix whatever it is preventing the cartridge from properly seating in the chamber.
MTHead
6 years ago
Beating a failure to feed into the chamber is compounding the problem. Never do that. Just rack another round, or fix the problem.
Now, go out in a nice quiet forest. And rack a round normally. Then ask yourself. Is that a noise I want to make when anyone in ear shot wants to kill me?
Now, try to slowly feed a round in the chamber. See where the bolt sticks? Now walk it home with the forward assist. Nice and quiet. That’s what it’s for.
sirlancelot
6 years ago
As a another poster mentioned that truck unit in Iraq did have a problem with their rifles due to lack of maintenance.
At least one soldier’s account stated his rifle would not properly fire . He used the forward assist ,shot the rifle and again had to use the forward assist to get his rifle to fire.
Apparently he did this throughout their engagement with the enemy. Don’t know what ponytail man’s background is but would rather hear from a veteran that’s actually used a particular rifle in combat.
Firing a rifle from a bench rest at the local gun club is completely different then having to take the same rifle to war.
Georgiaboy61
6 years ago
@ John Re: “There was a time when the Army had big problems with the powder that was being loaded into the 5.56×45. The fouling caused jams and gave the rifle a bad reputation that it earned because of the Army powder screwup. That is the main reason the assist was added.” The fiasco of the introduction of the M16 into the field and into combat in Vietnam is well-known. In fact, it is a matter of public record, since the Ichord Hearings took place in 1967-1968. It may very well have been the correct move to end production of the M-14 in favor of the AR15/M-16, America’s first assault rifle – but the decision to re-arm and re-equip the bulk of U.S. Army soldiers and U.S. Marines in theater while in the midst of a hot, on-going war – must rank as one of the worst blunders of all time by a sitting Secretary of Defense. Namely, Robert S. McNamara and his gang of “Whiz Kids.” Whatever difficulties had been experienced during the early stages of its production run by the manufacturers of the M-14 7.62 NATO service rifle, had largely been sorted out by the time U.S. involvement ramped up in SE Asia. The weapon worked as designed, and was well-liked by the troops. Most of the troops headed into harm’s way in Vietnam had trained on either the M-1 Garand or the M-14 service rifle as their primary weapon, or both in some cases. Many of those same soldiers and Marines were issued M-14s and used them in theater, including in combat. Others, however, who arrived a bit later, had trained on M-14s, but were issued the new M-16 upon arriving in Vietnam. Many of these troops did not receive more than a few hours cursory familiarization training, and some did not even have the opportunity to zero their weapons. Virtually none of the men had the opportunity to work with the rifle enough to become truly proficient and know it well, the way a combat infantryman ought to know his weapon. This blunder got good men killed. Cleaning kits were not issued, and many troops were told by their NCOs and officers that the new rifle was “self-cleaning,” and that no kits would be necessary. Nor were cleaning rods issued. This blunder got good men killed. Despite it being fairly common knowledge even at that time that chrome-plating the chamber, barrel and other interior surfaces of a rifle would aid in durability and resistance to corrosion, the AR15/M-16 had not been ordered with chrome-plating, so chief engineer Eugene Stoner did not design it into the weapon. If he raised questions or concerns about this decision, they were overruled. Once in theater in the hot, wet jungles and other extreme environments in SE Asia, these unprotected rifles began to rust almost immediately, many so severely they would not operate properly. Another blunder which killed good men. Unauthorized changes in the propellant used in the 5.56×45 NATO M193… Read more »
This article is filed under the category(s) AR-15s and was published July 30th, 2020 by Herschel Smith.
If you're interested in what else the The Captain's Journal has to say, you might try thumbing through the archives and visiting the main index, or; perhaps you would like to learn more about TCJ.
Leave it off. The only round I’d recommend a forward assist on an AR for would be 7.62 by 39. Very dirty blamo. Slick side are the way to go.
I have a BRN-605 upper on a build. Very nice piece of kit. Fast becoming my favorite configuration. KISS.
There was a time when the Army had big problems with the powder that was being
loaded into the 5.56×45. The fouling caused jams and gave the rifle a bad reputation
that it earned because of the Army powder screwup. That is the main reason the assist
was added. I understand the new stuff is supposed to work fine but I remember in
the first Iraq invasion that a truck outfit became lost, got into a firefight and was
rolled over and they captured the woman US soldier who was later rescued.
One of the top sergeants involved in the fiasco stated that their weapons malfunctuned
because the truckers “failed to properly lubricate their rifles”.
I used the M16 A1 rifle through the early and mid 70’s and having been bitten by jams,
I will never own one.
@John,
It’s odd how first impressions cause views for life.
I’ve never even once, in tens of thousands of rounds, had a FTF or FTE in any AR pattern rifle, and I’ve worked them pretty hard.
@ Herschel
It seems I’m like lhe guy who bought a lemon car from a particular company and avoided
their products for the rest of his life. I guess it’s old fashioned to be that way but since I’m
old myself I suppose I’m stuck with it. I do dearly love the M 14 and its clones.
All BCGs have a dished area that is accessible throught the ejection port that will give purchase to your thumb or a couple of fingers so you can apply a moderate amount of forward pressure to it. Applying any more force than that is the mechanical equivalent of bashing the end of the bolt on a bolt-action with a rubber mallet to force it into battery. Correcting a failure to feed or other OOB stoppage in this fashion is highly likely to further result in a failure to extract. In no case is a percussion adjustment likely to fix the root problem so instead of beating on the forward assist, better you should fix whatever it is preventing the cartridge from properly seating in the chamber.
Beating a failure to feed into the chamber is compounding the problem. Never do that. Just rack another round, or fix the problem.
Now, go out in a nice quiet forest. And rack a round normally. Then ask yourself. Is that a noise I want to make when anyone in ear shot wants to kill me?
Now, try to slowly feed a round in the chamber. See where the bolt sticks? Now walk it home with the forward assist. Nice and quiet. That’s what it’s for.
As a another poster mentioned that truck unit in Iraq did have a problem with their rifles due to lack of maintenance.
At least one soldier’s account stated his rifle would not properly fire . He used the forward assist ,shot the rifle and again had to use the forward assist to get his rifle to fire.
Apparently he did this throughout their engagement with the enemy. Don’t know what ponytail man’s background is but would rather hear from a veteran that’s actually used a particular rifle in combat.
Firing a rifle from a bench rest at the local gun club is completely different then having to take the same rifle to war.
@ John Re: “There was a time when the Army had big problems with the powder that was being loaded into the 5.56×45. The fouling caused jams and gave the rifle a bad reputation that it earned because of the Army powder screwup. That is the main reason the assist was added.” The fiasco of the introduction of the M16 into the field and into combat in Vietnam is well-known. In fact, it is a matter of public record, since the Ichord Hearings took place in 1967-1968. It may very well have been the correct move to end production of the M-14 in favor of the AR15/M-16, America’s first assault rifle – but the decision to re-arm and re-equip the bulk of U.S. Army soldiers and U.S. Marines in theater while in the midst of a hot, on-going war – must rank as one of the worst blunders of all time by a sitting Secretary of Defense. Namely, Robert S. McNamara and his gang of “Whiz Kids.” Whatever difficulties had been experienced during the early stages of its production run by the manufacturers of the M-14 7.62 NATO service rifle, had largely been sorted out by the time U.S. involvement ramped up in SE Asia. The weapon worked as designed, and was well-liked by the troops. Most of the troops headed into harm’s way in Vietnam had trained on either the M-1 Garand or the M-14 service rifle as their primary weapon, or both in some cases. Many of those same soldiers and Marines were issued M-14s and used them in theater, including in combat. Others, however, who arrived a bit later, had trained on M-14s, but were issued the new M-16 upon arriving in Vietnam. Many of these troops did not receive more than a few hours cursory familiarization training, and some did not even have the opportunity to zero their weapons. Virtually none of the men had the opportunity to work with the rifle enough to become truly proficient and know it well, the way a combat infantryman ought to know his weapon. This blunder got good men killed. Cleaning kits were not issued, and many troops were told by their NCOs and officers that the new rifle was “self-cleaning,” and that no kits would be necessary. Nor were cleaning rods issued. This blunder got good men killed. Despite it being fairly common knowledge even at that time that chrome-plating the chamber, barrel and other interior surfaces of a rifle would aid in durability and resistance to corrosion, the AR15/M-16 had not been ordered with chrome-plating, so chief engineer Eugene Stoner did not design it into the weapon. If he raised questions or concerns about this decision, they were overruled. Once in theater in the hot, wet jungles and other extreme environments in SE Asia, these unprotected rifles began to rust almost immediately, many so severely they would not operate properly. Another blunder which killed good men. Unauthorized changes in the propellant used in the 5.56×45 NATO M193… Read more »